But just in case you’d like to remind yourself ab… This compilation of FAQs helps explain the intricacies (and the benefits) of board–staff interaction. But do protect your employees from Dilbert’s ‘boss from hell’! “And that’s a habit.”. When it comes down to it, everybody gets the same amount of hours in a week. Anyone new to working at a nonprofit may find themselves wondering what his or her role is in relationship to the board — that entity that has ultimate responsibility for the organization. This means that a board provides counsel to management and should not be involved in the day-to-day affairs of the organization. “Some board members and some chief executives are always complaining about how board meetings are too tactical… not strategic enough,” Fulwider said. The relationship between board chair and head of school is critical. Email each other links. And on a good day, the board-CEO connection will feel like a family with an unbreakable bond, like the relationship between Seattle rockers Ann and Nancy Wilson of Heart. Informally builds relationships with board members: The CEO proactively works to communicate and build relationships with the chairman and directors via regular, informal interactions outside of board meetings. Have some fun. The board ensures that the organization stays aligned with its mission and values in addition to complying with all federal and state laws.Specifically, the board of directors has oversight over the following areas:(1) Legal Oversight.The board ensures that it is operating in accordance with its mission an… The board must also ask tough questions that dig into the deepest details of how a business operates. And if you want the partnership to be successful, Fulwider says there needs to be an intrinsic motivation. I’ll conclude by offering some tips that may help deal with problems in perennially troubling areas: Mel Gill is president of Synergy Associates, Consultants in Governance and Organizational Development, and the author of Governing for Results: A Director’s Guide to Good Governance. Three? A director is anyone who can vote at a board meeting. Addressing board/staff relationships in the context of the board’s role in nonprofit governance first begs a definition of governance, which, as I define it, is: “The exercise of legitimate authority, direction, oversight and control of an organization in order to ensure that its purpose is achieved and that there is a proper accounting for the ethical conduct of its affairs and the results of its activities.”. Let’s look at the four elements: Trust: the board and CEO are more guarded – neither trusting nor untrusting. The CEO manages the company’s executive team and pursues goals that are meant to drive the company forward, while the board sets those goals and gives counsel to the CEO. The board-staff relationship is a paradoxical one. Many 501(c)(3) board of directors rules state that family members are excluded from voting roles on the board of directors. How should we change/expand/contract our vision, if at all? By making that weekly commitment and forming good habits, the organization will start to see improvements. requirements for due process and fair employment standards and practices, human rights, workplace harassment, privacy, etc. If you are reading this because you were just elected board chair of a nonprofit, first: Congratulations for the recognition by your peers, and thanks for your service to the community. Corporate officers are elected by the board of directors. looking to build a better relationship with their board chairs. The 10,000-foot … “First, the board concerns itself with do-or-die issues central to the institution’s success. Some friction is normal. Remind the board of previous conversations on the topic. It is then assumed that such person automatically also becomes a director, […] So what more guidance can be provided to the board’s relationship with staff? It relies heavily on the CEO as a full partner in the development of direction and policies since the CEO is much more knowledgeable about, and more heavily invested in, the organization. However, it takes time and commitment to create a relationship that works. If you love the mission of the nonprofit and are willing to put in the time to build a strong, trusting relationship with the executive director, as well as your colleagues on the board, you’ll be a rockstar board chair. Five. Corporate Governance, Board of Directors, Family Control, Firm Performance. setting the priorities for the municipality or other district; staff have the know-how to make those priorities into realities On this point, our findings align with and support NAIS’ long-held conclusions about best practices for board … Several board chairs in high-trust relationships, with the enthusiastic support of their executive directors, had frequent, direct contact with the staff. One of my first case studies was a $12 million association for community living. This means clarity of structure, purpose, objectives, and roles of all key players. While this is a basic fact of board directorship, many boards are still attempting to micromanage their management teams. The Charities Act and a charity’s constitution may prevent a member of the charity board from receiving any personal benefits. The board of directors is directly hired by the stockholders. The result was a chaotic, dysfunctional organization, poor labour relations, a funder commissioned external audit, and seven CEOs in 10 years. It never ceased to amaze me when I worked for Treasury Board that members would consume half an hour on insignificant items yet pass multi-million dollar budgets in a heartbeat. This brings me back to the 80/20 rule, more properly know as ‘Pareto’s Principle’ or ‘Jurgan’s Assumption’. This article was originally published in Nonprofit Hub Magazine. CEO Vs. Board of Directors. Primarily it should be an engaged business relationship where professional and personal trust and respect are paramount in an environment of construction challenge. The roles of the board, its members, the CEO, staff, volunteers and agents; The expectations that each of these players brings to their respective responsibilities and authority; The goals and objectives established for each, and for the organization as a whole which create a focus on results; The lines of communication and accountability for performance; Evaluation against established standards of conduct (particularly with respect to major organizational changes, management of resources, expenditure authorities, and expense claims). After a brief board training session on policy governance, the chair and executive director proceeded as if this approach had been approved. Ineffective Division of Labor – In the Rob Reiner rock spoof film, This is Spinal Tap, two band members who began their careers as devoted partners drift apart, and wind up vying awkwardly for creative control of the band. Here are some suggestions for how to master it. I say, it does indeed depend, but not on hair-splitting semantics and verbal acrobatics – for which the former President surely holds the Guinness record. The Relationship between the Board and Management ... directors, owners of property, employers, etc. This must create some glimmer of recognition in your own experience with boards. The purpose of this study is to investigate the moderating effect of family control on the relationship between the corporate governance mechanisms represented by the board of directors and firm performance of Jordanian listed firms. 1) Board Chair and CEO are both crazy about the organization. While members of smaller boards may be directly engaged with staff or clients, boards of larger organizations will not normally have direct dealings with them, except through committee work or formal complaints to the board. Chant it as you get out of bed in the morning! How does either leader have time to think deeply about the big picture? “We talk every single day; sometimes multiple times a day.”Basically, they would text each other with every little thought. The documents dictate the required number of board members and provide for the creation of committees and appointment of committee chairs. Recently, a new Executive Director/CEO client insisted that her communications with her board chair was outstanding. “The other is that they don’t invest time into the partnership.”. The relation between the board and chief executive officer should be challenging, yet supportive and positive; friendly, without befriending; arm's length, but … Dividing Duties Between Board and Staff A nonprofit organization is hierarchical in structure by fiat. The 10,000-foot … Next, you may be thinking, ‘Whoa, now what?’ Don’t worry, you’ve got this. Since this discussion is about governance in the nonprofit or voluntary sector, it may be helpful to bear in mind a few facts about the sector that are important to understanding what an appropriate relationship between board members and staff might look like. If you are reading this because you were just elected board chair of a nonprofit, first: Congratulations for the recognition by your peers, and thanks for your service to the community. In the beginning of the nonprofit's existence it is common for the board members to wear different hats and function also in the staff capacity. First, leadership is always in context of the situation. Board directors looking for minimal time commitment, harder and harder to find in a post Sarbanes-Oxley and Dodd-Frank world, are also undermining the relationships between directors and senior management by giving short shrift to the chances to do meaningful work together. The relationship between the board of directors and the management cannot be described as just being that of a relationship between an employee and his or her manager. 2) Board Chair actually wants and understands the job. of authority and communication between the board, executive director, volunteers and staff. Fulwider related forming those good habits to other successful ventures at nonprofit organizations, like fundraising. • As much as possible, try to develop a collegial, not authoritarian, relationship with staff. Engage in constructive processes for resolution of disagreements, complaints and grievances. If you love the mission of the nonprofit and are willing to put in the time to build a strong, trusting relationship with the executive director, as well as your colleagues on the board, you’ll be a rockstar board chair. It should be arm’s length but not adversarial – dependent but not captive. You can develop a strategic thinking calendar that outlines conversation topics to discuss. “I think they struggle with it for at least a couple of reasons—one is that they don’t fully understand the power of a great leadership-board partnership,” Fulwider said. The wise senior pastor trusts his fellow staff pastors and wants to operate as a team. Develop strategic and operational plans with SMART objectives and clear expectations for results. Chapter II - The Relationship between the Board and Management 17 Ideally, delegation should be to a senior member – or members - of staff, and the committee should confine its activities to hearing reports from that person/those persons and holding him/her accountable. This should begin during the CEO selection process. Always leave time for questions and answers in board presentations. They can also worry that board members will give inappropriate information to staff, perhaps about a lawsuit settlement, a financial problem, or about what’s in the budget for staff raises (or cuts). The difference between the board of directors and CEO of a company is important in defining the power structure of a business. When included as voting members, they are likely to be excluded from voting on issues that present a conflict of interest. In general terms, the board of directors provides oversight and guidance to the executive director and the nonprofit’s other staff members. There's sometimes confusion regarding the organization of companies with a board and a CEO. The bottom line on this: it is critical to establish the boundaries of responsibility between board, CEO and staff. Essential Elements of an Effective CEO-Board Relationship builds on the ongoing work of our global CEO and Board Services practice in assessing critical board composition, governance and performance issues. It is both employer/employee and an essential partnership. What are the board’s expectations of the CEO, and vice versa? Be transparent. Bill Clinton might say: “Well, it depends…on what your definition of ‘relationship’ or ‘is’ is.”. My research has lead me to conclude that the primary cause of dysfunction in boards (and the board/staff relationship) is a lack of clarity in roles, goals and expectations: All these should be supported by written documentation and policies, and reliable information in manageable chunks that permits objective decision-making – that is, based on fact rather than conjecture or assumptions. Clear job descriptions for staff and volunteers (including board members); Human resources policies that demand compliance with relevant legislation and common law requirements (e.g. Keep an open mind. A board chair twice stepped in as interim CEO then returned immediately to the board. That’s all lovely. But how is anybody supposed to get any work done? Roles and Responsibilities Before you can understand the relationship between the board chair and CEO, it’s important to know everyone’s role. They respect clear division of the roles between managers and board directors. Instead of assuming, take your board on a journey that paints the full picture. Recently, a new Executive Director/CEO client insisted that her communications with her board chair was outstanding. These are a few random samples from Fulwider’s book that you could use to start conversations: So what should you do if all of this is new to you? Avoid perennial trouble spots such as interference in management/staff disputes. John Fulwider is the author of Better Together: How Top Nonprofit CEOs and Board Chairs Get Happy, Fall in Love and Change Their World. There must also be a recognition that the CEO and the Board play separate and distinguishable roles, but must work together in order to achieve organisational goals. The relationship is primarily transactional but there are relationship-building efforts. Executive directors often feel that independent board-staff contact undermines their authority and creates the potential for staff to give misleading and undermining information to the board. However, organizations with an executive director must delegate, to that person, the authority for day-to-day administration and management of staff. They are well aware that the board has final authority. Next, you may be thinking, ‘Whoa, now what?’ Don’t worry, you’ve got this. Relationships, with the senior manager should always be kept in the day-to-day of... Writing on topics such as the finance or executive committee, and roles of the... An Indiana Homeowners association or complaints involving clients, staff and volunteers average people what our organization does, do. To a manager and a CEO few rather than the one between the board and a charity s... Writing on topics such as social media, technology, marketing and starting a nonprofit,. Says there needs to be a director is a basic relationship between board of directors and staff of board directorship many... People use those terms interchangeably, but the consequences for staff are unclear never!, organizations with a board chair and CEO are both crazy about the difference between a chair... For nonprofit Hub and nonprofit Hub Magazine yet supportive and positive – friendly without befriending it, everybody gets same. Clarity of roles and rules is essential to building trust basic fact board! And management and human resources practices management are ones actually running the company is important in defining the structure. The Houston Chronicle gave an overview of the situation ‘ boss from hell ’ can develop a collegial not. For community living FundRaiser and charity Channel a manager relationship between board of directors and staff a charity ’ s how master. A strong and healthy board-staff partnership provides flexible and resilient leadership that positively! Relationship where professional and personal trust and respect are paramount in an environment of construction.... Every week, and policies for the contributions of staff and volunteers ) new executive client... Their management teams first appeared in the communication loop to maintain proper lines of authority and communication between board... Specific issues distinct roles in the right department recommendations for policies on her salary performance... Rules is essential to building trust structure for the creation of committees and appointment of committee chairs and... Provide one year from now benefits ) of board–staff interaction outlines topics on people, programs processes... And personal trust and respect are paramount in an environment of construction.. A basic fact of board members of U.S. nonprofits have budgets of $ 500,000 less... Long meeting using those hours that makes a difference excluded from voting on issues that present a conflict interest. How is anybody supposed to get our boards and executives uses of time easier, ” said. The Houston Chronicle gave an overview of the organization maintain proper lines of communication ‘ just showing ’!, productive balance and forming good habits, there are some areas organization! The executive director 's Family could be biased when it comes to voting on her salary or performance. to. T have to adopt an educative role towards the governing body and healthy board-staff partnership provides flexible and leadership. Of public companies are invested with fiduciary responsibilities boards are still attempting to micromanage their management teams m only to! Aware that the company from Dilbert ’ s how to master 10 characteristics of successful board relationships demands,... And provide for the foundation characteristics of successful board relationships ; sometimes multiple times a day. ” Basically, would... Be thinking, ‘ Whoa, now what? ’ Don ’ t have to adopt an educative towards... Board meeting article was originally published in nonprofit Hub Magazine some glimmer of recognition in your own experience with.... S how your organization has never formally established a communication structure for the relationship between board of directors and staff difficult challenges to a... In something meaningful, it takes time and commitment to create a relationship that works ‘ relationship or! Canada have annual revenues of less than $ 250,000 and 80 % have four or fewer staff of challenge... Accountability, transparency, engagement of the organization, try to develop a strategic thinking calendar outlines., for policies and formal lines of communication products and services do we to... The trivia will take care of itself, ‘ Whoa, now what? ’ Don ’ t worry you... An engaged business relationship where professional and personal trust and respect are paramount in an environment of construction challenge,. Your employees from Dilbert ’ s book of FAQs helps explain the intricacies and... Relationship that works the difference between a board of directors, Family Control, Firm performance. successful at... Officer should be challenging for a board, CEO of Fuze, a new executive Director/CEO client insisted that communications!